Being a Christian in an Election Year

It's election year and once again I find myself rethinking what it means to be Christian in the midst of presidential campaign season. But before I get into what I'm currently thinking I'd like to take just a moment to rewind and give you a quick history of me, my faith and presidential elections. I realize it's a short history but nonetheless...

2000
This was the first presidential election I was old enough to vote in. In the primary I was rooting for Dan Quayle and in the general election I voted for George W. Bush. And let me tell you, I voted FOR Bush. It wasn't an ambivalent vote or a "lesser of two evils" vote. I believed in George W. Bush. I thought he was going to be great. I had a big cut out of his head taped down in my CD case along with other pop-culture paraphernalia. While I never saw Al Gore as "unChristian" (he's Baptist) I definitely understood Bush to be the "Christian candidate." This was my freshman year in college and I was still deeply influenced by a fundamentalist understanding of Christianity. As I walked through the halls of the Christian ministry department at my college I saw that one professors had a Clinton/Gore bumper sticker on their door. It shocked me. I had never encountered a Christian who was "pro-Clinton." Another professor had a sign in his office saying "Jesus was a Liberal." At this point in my faith and in my college carreer such moments were logic-defying for me.

2004
My second go-round found me much less optimistic than before. My views on politics had changed drastically thanks to Christians like John Howard Yoder - a Mennonite pacifist, Stanley Hauerwas - a Methodist theologian, Dietrich Bonhoeffer - an underground Lutheran pastor in Nazi Germany... and many others. I no longer had any "hope" in the American government, I was becoming more and more enchanted with God's kingdom and God's restoration of creation and at the same time less and less impressed with the American kingdom and it's attempts at fixing the world by dominating it. During this election the driving issues for me were the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. I shrugged my shoulders and voted for Kerry. I didn't expect Kerry to buy into God's radical plan of change and shalom but he was the "lesser of two evils" from my perspective. So I half-heartedly tossed a vote his way in 2004. Just FYI, Nader wasn't on the ballot in Missouri.

2008
Here we go again, round three. As I've posted before, I don't plan on voting this time. Partly because I was getting really excited about Obama. I kept finding myself really hoping he would become president and bring some fundamental change to our country. It scared me. It was easy to get caught up in the hoopla of Obamania... and lose sight who I really believe will bring fundamental change in the world. Thanks to Obama's subtle shift to the right, I've become much more skeptical of him and am frustrated with enough that I no longer have such temptations. This kind of detached skepticism is where I would want to be as a Christian in the voting process, but at least this year I'm still planning to give away my vote to someone who is voiceless.

More and more I'm beginning to appreciate the political perspective of people like Dr. Martin Luther King. His idea was, don't endorse anybody. Endorsing a candidate just makes it easy for them to count you as a part of their base and then move on and ignore you. Instead, King advocated inviting politicians on both sides to endorse your movement, your platform and to do so all through the campaign and on through their time in office. I think this way guards us from the danger of getting yanked around by parties and also guards us against buying into their agenda as a compromise for the influence we think we have.

Shane Claiborne has a great article about this way of engaging politics as a Christian called "Advise Everyone, Endorse No One." Check it out here. I think Shane's take on it is a healthy blend of King's emphasis on being influential without being co-opted and with a robust skepticism of American politics in light of the Kingdom of God.

Zack Exley over at Revolution in Jesusland recently posted about McLaren and the Matthew 25 Network's endorsement of Obama. While I'm not one to champion Christian groups endorsing (I like Shane's approach better), this is the way to do it if they must.

Labels: Life, Politics, Theology